Skip to content

Guide · Selling

How to sell gold jewelry for a fair price

A step-by-step plan for selling rings, chains and broken jewelry, from sorting by karat to comparing written offers.

Last updated October 8, 2026

Work out what your gold is worth before anyone makes you an offer. It takes about an hour.

1. Sort your pieces by karat

Look for a small stamp inside a ring band or near a clasp. Use a magnifying glass or your phone camera zoomed in.

Stamp Karat Pure gold
10K, 417 10 karat 41.7%
14K, 585 14 karat 58.3%
18K, 750 18 karat 75.0%
22K, 916 22 karat 91.7%
24K, 999 24 karat 99.9%

Put each karat in its own bag. A buyer who weighs everything together may price the whole pile at the lowest karat.

Some stamps mean plated, not solid. See how to tell if gold is real.

2. Weigh each bag

A kitchen scale that reads in grams to 0.1 g is good enough for a first estimate. Remove stones if they are loose or cheap: a buyer will not pay gold prices for them, and many will deduct an estimate for their weight.

3. Work out the melt value

Melt value is weight × purity × today’s gold price. Our calculator does the math. No buyer can pay full melt and stay in business, but you now know what “fair” looks like.

4. Get at least two written offers

  • Visit two or three buyers. Our directory lists shops near you, and you can check a dealer’s license first.
  • Ask for the offer in writing, broken down by karat and weight.
  • Ask which gold price they used, and when it was set.
  • Ask about any testing or “appraisal” fee, especially one that only applies if you say no.

5. Compare offers as a percent of melt

Type each offer into the calculator. It shows what percent of melt you are being offered. Compare that number, not the dollar amount.

6. Keep anything that might be worth more than its metal

Signed designer pieces, antique jewelry, and pieces with real gemstones can be worth more to a jeweller or auction house than to a scrap buyer. Get one opinion from a jeweller before you sell these for melt.

Before you hand anything over

  • Watch your items being weighed, on a scale you can see.
  • Do not leave items “to be tested” without a signed receipt listing every piece.
  • Bring a photo ID. Most states require buyers to record it.
  • If you feel rushed, leave. A fair offer will still be fair tomorrow, give or take the gold price.

Next guide

Selling inherited gold and silver

← All guides